At New Glarus Bakery, we specialize in crafting exquisite cakes that are perfect for any occasion. Our cakes are made with the finest ingredients and baked to perfection, ensuring a delicious and satisfying experience with every bite. Whether you’re celebrating a special milestone, hosting a party, or simply treating yourself to something sweet, our cakes are sure to impress. And with a variety of sizes and customization options available, yours is sure to be one-of-a-kind. Browse our selection of cakes today for inspiration and discover the perfect dessert for your next event or celebration!
Cakes are only available for pick-up or local delivery, within the New Glarus, WI area.
Looking for Inspiration? View our Tailored Cake Portfolio.
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/8 Sheet Cake
- $22.00 – $24.20
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 12)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/4 Sheet Cake
- $39.00 – $42.90
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 24)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom 1/2 Sheet Cake
- $55.00 – $60.50
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 48)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Sheet Cakes
Custom Full Sheet Cake
- $80.00 – $88.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *Requires a $20 non-refundable deposit. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 96)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Tasting Cake
- $25.00
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 6″ Round Cake
- $25.00 – $27.50
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 8)
-
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Round Cakes
Custom 8″ Round Cake
- $39.00 – $42.90
- Please review our cake order guidelines for details on pickup timelines, serving sizes, etc. *All custom cake orders will be verified / confirmed with you prior to baking. (Max Servings 20)
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 2 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" bottom (Max Servings 28) 6" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 58) 6" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 68) 8" top, 10" bottom (Max Servings 70) 8" top, 12" bottom (Max Servings 80) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Select options
- Tailored Cakes, Tailored Wedding Cakes
Wedding Cake – 3 Tier
- Start here to design your wedding cake. 6" top, 8" middle, 10" bottom (Max Servings 75) 6" top, 8" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 95) 6" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 110) 8" top, 10" middle, 12" bottom (Max Servings 120) Choose your favorite cake and filling combinations Upload images of the designs you have in mind.
-
-
-
-
-
-